Behavioral Scoring: The Key to Unlocking Smarter Marketing
Imagine this: You’re pouring time, energy, and resources into marketing campaigns, but your leads aren’t converting. Emails are being ignored, website visitors vanish without a trace, and your sales team is frustrated with unqualified prospects. Sound familiar?
In today’s hyper-competitive, data-driven world, marketers face three universal challenges:
Reaching the right audience: Without clear insights into behaviors that signal genuine interest, your message gets lost in the noise.
Aligning marketing and sales teams: A lack of actionable data leads to misaligned efforts, wasted opportunities, and finger-pointing.
Timing outreach effectively: Reaching out too early can scare off potential buyers; too late, and they’ve already gone elsewhere.
These pain points are the reality for countless professionals trying to make sense of their audience's digital footprints. But what if there were a way to cut through the chaos and turn these challenges into opportunities?
Why Behavioral Scoring Is the Game-Changer You Need
Behavioral scoring isn’t just about assigning points—it’s about decoding your audience’s journey. By tracking their actions, you can answer crucial questions: Who’s ready to buy? Who needs nurturing? And how can you tailor your messaging to meet them where they are?
Done right, behavioral scoring can:
✅ Bridge the gap between marketing and sales with clear, actionable insights.
✅ Pinpoint and prioritize high-intent leads so your team can focus on what matters.
✅ Optimize your outreach strategy, ensuring the right message reaches the right person at the right time.
This guide will show you how to build a scoring model that aligns with your unique funnel stages, helping you maximize every interaction. Whether you’re a HubSpot power user or working with another platform, the steps outlined here will help you create a system that turns engagement into conversions.
Table of Contents
Step 1: Building the Foundation
Outlining Funnel Stages
Understanding the Customer Decision-Making Process
Step 2: Assigning Points to Specific Behaviors
Key Questions to Guide Scoring
Sample Behavioral Scoring Model
Step 3: Segmenting Your Database
Generic Marketing Funnel Segments
Hyper-Focused Marketing Funnels
Step 4: Automating the Journey
Drip Campaigns for Each Funnel Stage
Aligning with Your Marketing Content Calendar
Ready to take your marketing strategy to the next level? Let’s get started! 🚀
Step 1: Outline your marketing funnel stages
Build the Foundation: Start with Your Marketing Funnel
Before you set up a behavioral scoring model, it’s essential to first outline your marketing funnel and its stages. Without this foundation, assigning meaningful scores is impossible. Behavioral scoring only works when tied to clear stages in your customer’s journey, ensuring that every score reflects progress toward a decision.
Why This Step Matters
Your audience isn’t monolithic. Every prospect is on a unique journey and at different stages of decision-making. Behavioral scoring allows you to meet them where they are, but only if you understand:
What prompts their interest?
How your solution addresses their needs.
Why you’re a better option than competitors.
By targeting them with relevance and precision, you increase the likelihood of moving them closer to conversion.
Key Marketing Funnel Stages
If you're unsure where to start, here's a recommended framework:
Awareness (Top of the Funnel: Score 0–10)
Prospect realizes they have a problem or opportunity.
Example Behaviors: Reading blog posts, engaging with social media content.
Interest (Middle of the Funnel: Score 11–29)
Prospect begins exploring potential solutions.
Example Behaviors: Downloading an eBook, attending a webinar, signing up for a newsletter.
Consideration (Bottom of the Funnel: Score 30–39)
Prospect evaluates your solution against competitors.
Example Behaviors: Viewing case studies, visiting product or service pages.
Marketing Qualified / Sales Ready (Score 40+)
Prospect shows clear buying intent.
Example Behaviors: Submitting a “Request a Demo” form, visiting the pricing page.
The Decision-Making Process
Your funnel stages should align with the natural progression of decision-making:
Status Quo – The prospect is comfortable with their current situation.
Disruption – They realize a need for change.
Discussion – They start conversations internally or externally.
Research – They evaluate solutions.
Deliberation – They weigh options.
Decision – They choose a solution.
Now that you have your scoring stages identified, and your scoring thresholds per each stage, we can move onto assigning points per behavior.
Step 2: Assigning Points to Specific Behaviors
Now that your funnel stages are established, it’s time to tackle the next critical component: assigning points to behaviors. These points act as indicators of intent, reflecting how actions align with your marketing funnel and the journey your prospects take.
To set up an effective scoring model, start by answering key questions that will shape your point allocations:
Key Questions for Behavioral Scoring
How long is the sales cycle?
Example: If your sales cycle averages 90 days, set up a rolling date range for scoring to reflect recent and relevant behaviors. For instance, a form submission within the last 90 days might score +10, but older activity could decay over time.
How many email clicks, page views, form submissions, or asset downloads does a record need to complete to become qualified?
Example: A contact might need to click on at least 3 emails, view 5 pages, or download a whitepaper before being considered "engaged" enough to move to the middle of the funnel.
What is the average number of email opens or clicks per contact in the current marketing automation platform?
Example: If the average contact clicks on 2 emails during their journey, set 7 points per click. This way, a highly engaged contact reaching 21 points could signal readiness to move further in the funnel.
What is the average number of page views per website visitor?
Example: If visitors typically view 4 pages, assign 5 points per page. Contacts with 20+ points might be showing above-average interest, signaling they’re moving closer to the decision stage.
Which behaviors should instantly qualify a record?
Example: Actions like submitting a "Request a Demo" form, visiting the pricing page, or attending a webinar can signal high intent. Assign these behaviors 40 points each, automatically marking the contact as sales-qualified (MQL).
These questions and examples provide the foundation for designing a scoring model tailored to your audience's unique behaviors and journey.
Sample Behavioral Scoring Model
Opened an email: 0 points
Why? Opens often result from false positives like auto-previewing.
Clicked an email: 7 points
Reflects engagement and a step toward interest.
Clicked a CTA: 5 points
Shows intent to explore further but may not yet indicate buying intent.
Submitted any form: 10 points
Baseline for general interest, except high-intent forms like demos.
Submitted a high-intent form (e.g., Request a Demo): 40 points
Direct indicator of sales readiness.
Visited a web page: 7 points
Requires adjustment based on the average number of pages viewed.
Attended a webinar: 35 points
Reflects significant interest in learning about your solution.
Setting Rolling Date Ranges
Behavioral scores must decay over time to stay relevant. Assign points within a specific timeframe, like 90 or 180 days, based on your sales cycle.
For example: A "Submitted Form" action taken within the last 90 days should score 10 points, but the same form submission outside this range would score 0.
Important Considerations
Avoid Merging Profile and Behavior Scoring
Behavioral Scoring is strictly action-based.
Profile Scoring focuses on attributes like job title, industry, or geographic location.
Why separate them? Mixing the two dilutes the accuracy of your funnel, as behaviors reflect intent, while profiles reflect potential.
Avoid Negative Scoring
Negative scoring is often used to penalize behaviors like visiting a career page.
Instead of manipulating scores, use segmentation tools to filter these contacts out of your funnel.
Example: Create a separate list for career-page visitors, ensuring they don’t interfere with your lead flow without reducing their behavioral scores.
Step 3: Segmenting Your Database Based on Behavior
Once your scoring system is in place, the next step is to segment your database. Behavioral scoring becomes actionable when it's paired with proper segmentation, enabling you to target groups effectively with tailored content.
Now that we’ve combined all these various behaviors into a single point system, segmentation becomes much more streamlined and powerful. Instead of creating individual segments for email clicks, form submissions, and website activity, we can now focus on overall engagement levels. This holistic approach allows you to see the complete picture of how a contact interacts with your brand, rather than isolating specific actions.
Remember, everyone engages with content differently. Some leads may click through emails, while others prefer consuming blog posts or attending webinars. By consolidating these behaviors into a unified scoring model, we avoid siloed reports and gain a deeper understanding of overall engagement trends. This ensures that your segmentation accurately reflects true interest and intent, giving you the ability to deliver highly relevant content at the right time.
Start with the Generic Marketing Funnel
The Generic Marketing Funnel is a broad segmentation that classifies all records based strictly on their behavioral score. This high-level segmentation is invaluable for analyzing your database but is too generic for targeted content outreach. It allows you to see where your entire database falls—top, middle, bottom of the funnel, or marketing qualified (MQL).
Generic Marketing Funnel Segments
Top of the Funnel (TOFU):
Criteria: Score is less than 10.
Purpose: Reflects new or low-engagement contacts with minimal interaction.
Middle of the Funnel (MOFU):
Criteria: Score is between 11 and 29.
Purpose: Reflects moderate engagement but still exploratory.
Bottom of the Funnel (BOFU):
Criteria: Score is between 30 and 40.
Purpose: Reflects contacts showing strong interest and nearing readiness to convert.
Marketing Qualified / Sales Ready (MQL):
Criteria: Score is greater than or equal to 40.
Purpose: Indicates a high level of intent and readiness for sales engagement.
Best Practices for Creating the Generic Funnel
Decide whether to include all records or narrow it down to specific categories, such as leads or contacts tagged for marketing.
Use this segmentation for data analysis only, such as tracking the distribution of your database across funnel stages or identifying which stages need more attention.
Move to the Hyper-Focused Marketing Funnel
After establishing the generic funnel, it's time to create Hyper-Focused Funnels. These segments combine behavioral scores with specific attributes or demographics, providing a more granular view of your audience.
Example of a Hyper-Focused Marketing Funnel
Let’s say your company specializes in targeting industries like Software, Data Technologies, and IT. Here's how you might define your funnel:
Top of the Funnel (TOFU):
Criteria: Score is less than 10 AND Industry is any of: Software, Data Technologies, IT.
Middle of the Funnel (MOFU):
Criteria: Score is between 11 and 29 AND Industry is any of: Software, Data Technologies, IT.
Bottom of the Funnel (BOFU):
Criteria: Score is between 30 and 40 AND Industry is any of: Software, Data Technologies, IT.
Marketing Qualified / Sales Ready (MQL):
Criteria: Score is greater than or equal to 40 AND Industry is any of: Software, Data Technologies, IT.
Key Questions to Guide Your Hyper-Focused Funnel Creation:
Who are we targeting in this segment?
Define industries, roles, or other key attributes.
What content do we have for each stage?
Ensure your content is ready to address their needs at TOFU, MOFU, BOFU, or MQL stages.
What are their unique challenges and priorities?
Use this knowledge to craft highly relevant and timely messages.
Practical Uses of Funnel Segments
Generic Funnels: Analyze the health of your database and assess engagement distribution.
Hyper-Focused Funnels: Deliver personalized, relevant outreach campaigns that
Why Funnel Segmentation Matters
Segmenting your database by behavioral score ensures that you:
Target the right audience with the right content at the right time.
Maximize engagement by addressing specific needs based on both intent and profile.
Increase efficiency by focusing your marketing and sales efforts on the most relevant opportunities.
Increase email deliverability by sending more emails to those that are engaging and slowing down email sends for those that are not.
Proper segmentation ensures your scoring model isn’t just a theoretical exercise but a powerful tool for driving results.
Section 4: Automating the Journey – Workflows for Every Funnel Stage
With your hyper-focused segments in place, it’s time to create automated workflows (drip campaigns) tailored to each stage of the marketing funnel. These workflows nurture your leads based on where they are in their decision-making process, ensuring every touchpoint is relevant, engaging, and effective.
Below is an example of the types of emails we would create for each funnel stage and Computer Software, Data Technologies and IT as the example industries:
Top of Funnel (Disrupt, Attract, Capture)
Focus: Problem-Oriented Messaging
Source List: Top of Funnel Segment (Score < 10)
Exit Condition: Not in Top of Funnel Segment (Score ≥ 10)
Approach: Universal messaging through multi-channel efforts: email, social media, blogs, PPC, and more.
Engagement Campaign: Start with 5 touchpoints, gradually expand to 12.
Example Messaging Ideas:
"10 Tips for Streamlining Your Data Operations"
"5 Ways to Improve Marketing Efficiency Today"
"Did you know? 32% of CEOs say their biggest challenge is aligning marketing and sales."
Middle of Funnel (Educate, Evaluate, Engage)
Focus: Solution-Oriented Messaging
Source List: Middle of Funnel Segment (Score 11–29)
Exit Condition: Not in Middle of Funnel Segment (Score ≥ 30)
Approach: Provide actionable solutions to address identified pain points.
Engagement Campaign: Start with 5 touchpoints, gradually expand to 12.
Example Messaging Ideas:
"Struggling with ABC Problem? Here's How XYZ Solution Can Help."
"3 Ways Our Solution Solves Your Pain Points."
"Webinar Invite: How to Solve [Specific Challenge] in Just 30 Days."
Bottom of Funnel (Convince, Convert, Close)
Focus: Differentiation-Oriented Messaging
Source List: Bottom of Funnel Segment (Score 30–40)
Exit Condition: Sales Engagement or Contact Form Submission
Approach: Highlight why your solution is the best choice with clear differentiation.
Engagement Campaign: 3–7 touchpoints for high-impact conversion-focused messaging.
Example Messaging Ideas:
"Why Choose Us? See What Sets Us Apart."
"Customer Success: How [Company Name] Achieved [Result] with Our Solution."
"Request a Demo Today and Unlock Exclusive Benefits."
"Limited Time Offer: Schedule an Appointment and Receive [Discount/Incentive]."
Notable Fact:
90% of decision-makers find personalized, data-driven messaging critical when selecting a vendor.
Drip Campaign Conclusion
By creating targeted workflows for each stage of your marketing funnel, you ensure every lead receives relevant, timely, and impactful content. This approach not only increases engagement but also accelerates their journey through the funnel, maximizing conversions and ROI.
Ready to get started? Download our free Custom Behavioral Scoring Model to begin building your own scoring system today!
Final Thought: Behavioral Scoring as a Journey
Remember, no two leads are the same. Some prospects will hit MQL status on day one, while others might take months to progress. By carefully considering all use cases and assigning points thoughtfully, you create a scoring model that reflects both individual journeys and organizational goals.
This approach allows you to focus your marketing efforts on sending the right message, to the right person, at the right time.
Case Studies: Behavioral Scoring in Action
Example 1: Software Company
A software provider implemented behavioral scoring based on actions such as webinar attendance and demo requests. By aligning scores with funnel stages, they reduced lead qualification time by 30% and increased MQL conversions by 20%.
Example 2: Educational Institution
A university focused on prospective student behavior—page visits and content downloads. Behavioral scoring helped them identify high-value prospects, increasing enrollment rates.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Mixing Profile and Behavior Scoring: This dilutes the value of your model.
Overcomplicating Scoring: Start simple, then refine based on results.
Ignoring Decay: Without rolling date ranges, old behaviors skew the score.
Conclusion: Power Your Growth with Behavioral Scoring
By integrating a thoughtful behavioral scoring system into your marketing automation strategy, you can deliver personalized experiences, align your teams, and drive meaningful results.
I hope you have enjoyed the blog/guide. This topic is something I cover regularly. This same methodology can apply to any type of business. We have used behavior scoring for Ivy School recruitment, employment and fundraising. There really is no limit to how you can implement a behavior scoring model. Cheers!
Comments